Makeup Brand TIER LIST// Ranking brands from BEST to WORST… This was so hard
Ranking popular mainstream makeup brands using tier list! Which brands are my favorites and which brands am I bored of?
~ S U B S C R I B E ~
———
FOLLOW ME:
Instagram: @_KellyGooch
Tik Tok: @_KellyGooch
———
VIDEOS MENTIONED:
Full Face of Bare Minerals:
Full Face of Urban Decay:
———
BINGE-WORTHY PLAYLISTS:
Low-Buy Guide:
Makeup Tutorials:
How To Go Cruelty Free:
———
WHAT I’M WEARING:
Eyes: ELF Cream & Sugar Quad
Lips: Persona Almond + Urban Decay Stark Naked + Becca Rose Gold
Earrings: Kendra Scott
Necklace: Ana Luisa
IN MY BACKGROUND:
Target Lamp:
Fake Fern:
———
DISCOUNTS & CODES
– Sigma Beauty: Code “KELLYG” for 10% (affiliate)
Shop Here:
– Kokie Cosmetics: Code “KELLY25” for 25% off (affiliate)
Shop here:
– Ofra Cosmetics: Code: “KELLYG” for 20% off (affiliate)
Shop here:
– Ebates provides cash back when shopping online. Sign up and receive a $10 welcome bonus.
Sign up here: (referral link)
– Magic Links helps creators earn commission from product links!
Sign Up here: (referral link)
———
FAQ:
What is your skin type? Normal to dry
What camera do you use?
How do you do your hair?
What editing software do you use? Wondershare Filmora
How old are you? 27
———
FTC: Affiliate links are used (typically start with magic.ly or rstyle.me). If you purchase through the links, I may receive a small commission. This video is not sponsored. All opinions are my own and always will be!
Source link
Your face shape, hair and facial expressions remind me of Victoria Justice but in lighter complexion.
Rimmel
I loved this video! I agree about Bare Minerals. I did laugh because Tarte is a “Give me everything” for me. Lol. There is an Indy brand Karity that you should check out, there shadows are AMAZING!
Smashbox primer is my holy grail, but I don't use anything else from the brand.
I haven't been excited by anything Tarte for so long but their new Hydroflex Serum foundation is amazing!
I would love to see a drugstore only list and an indie list and an influencer list.
@Melthompson sent me here. Enjoying your content. Thank you❤️🌸
Omg this is fun! I may have to do this 💓
The CC or BB cream from smash box is really good and their bullet lipsticks are *chefs kiss, super creamy
I personally would put ELF in the top spot, I agree that bare minerals is underrated- I would put it in big fan category. I would put Milani in big fan too. CP in absolutely not.I would put UD in take it or leave it. Everything else I agree with.
I feel the opposite with Too Faced, I snag most of their collection 💛
So for me all these brands would be in absolutely not except for elf. Nyx and colourpop which would be in I’m bored xxx
I never noticed until this.. I have never tried so many popular brands. Or just like one of those always free sample mascaras and thats it. Never tried stila, tarte and only 1 pallet from UD never tried smashbox, and only one eye cream from bare minerals.
I totally respect your rankings, as brands and products are so personal. Stating that, I agree with many of your rankings….great video❣️🥰
Fun idea! I’d love to see a brand like tarte make a comeback on the cream blush trend since their clay blushes are so iconic. Same for UD – I wish they could surprise us with some multi or duo chrome palettes or singles that can bring those shades to the mainstream.
Give me everything: Bare Minerals
Big Fan: BECCA, Urban Decay, ABH
Take It Or Leave It: elf, NYX, Milani
I'm Bored: Tarte, Colourpop, Smashbox
No: Too Faced, Stila
Smashbox isn’t cruelty free are they??
My "Give Me Everything" brands are MUG & Cover FX. 🤗
But have you tried odenseye yet? I feel like you would love them!
I lovee your video!!! And i really understand your rating! Can you do one including indie brands???
The smashbox always on cream to matte lipsticks are amazing. I think they came out last year. I have a lot of old favorites from them so that keeps them alive for me. But the cream to matte formula on their lipsticks is one of my favorites.
What has Too Faced done that Kelly doesn't agree with? What happened?
You should definitely try the new smashbox cream eyeshadows, they are so beautiful and easy to work with, they actually made me an eyeshadow-person (I never used to wear eyeshadow and now I wear them every day)
I “like” a lot of Smashbox products, but don’t get super excited by them. Notable exception: the Cali Contour palette, which I LOVE!
I love the Smashbox Super Fan mascara, but yeah I'm bored with them.
Smash box has my favorite foundation hands down. 24 hour hydration. Tried so many others and always come back. Perfect match. Also love their always sharp eyeliner. Perfection
I think that your ranking seems to be like a real life person, not a you tuber. When I worked in a makeup store most average people are al about the ud and bare minerals. So that was refreshing
I think we definitely would love a round 2 of this video! Or even 3! 😀
It makes me so sad that smashbox is so unpopular. They were my very first high-end brand, and their mini eye shadow palettes were the very first compliment I ever got on my eye look! It absolutely made my day! They will always have a special place in my heart, even though I guess I only still have their primers…. but they work amazingly on ma oily skin!
Smashbox Cali contour palette
Smashbox step by step contour palette
Awesome idea! I think I would have, obviously, sorted them a bit differently, but in general my "I'm bored" and "Take it or leave it" would be absolutely overflowing hahaha. But you are missing some brands, I would love to hear your thoughts on: ND, Ofra, Bh, Milk, Kaleidos Essence, etc. So please consider a second part 🥰
Idk if this would apply to you, but I decided to break up my palette ranking into 3 different types this year. First ranking them just by color story, then just by formula. Then a 3rd post being the overall ranking. To me I just noticed they move around so much within those 3 categories, that it doesn't do them justice to only do the last one. But I know you've done formula rankings etc recently too, so this is just an idea! ❤
The bare mineral blushes are amazing I have mauve sunrise and pink sky from the bounce and blur collection
Thanks for making this industry fun again on Youtube! I love your research and presentation and I'm gaining interest in makeup again because of your videos 🙂 And I'm learning a lot!
You are right, Bare Minerals has been at the top of my list lately!
I definitely must agree with your choices for ELF and Colourpop. I do really love ELF but they do seem to be coming out with different selections collections now and Colourpop is a definite yes! They just continuously put out collections one after another. I only have one palette I like from them, that’s the My Little Pony palette the only other items I like are their lip products.
The only product that I’ve liked from Smashbox is the Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye Primer! It’s the only thing so far that I’ve felt has helped my under eye dark circles(I’m young but they sometimes get dark) and also helps my concealer to stay in place!
I need to try more of Milani before deciding but otherwise I pretty much agree with your choices with one huge exception being Urban Decay. They are in my absolutely not category. I have been so uninterested for a very long time now. Love bareminerals tho!
This was such a cool video idea! I absolutely loved watching it💕 Please make a Part 2!!
Bare Minerals has been my favor since the 90's. They have the best powder foundations. Thanks for sharing!
Absolutely not: Morphe. I like their sponges but the continued sale of James Charles turns me off.
I’m bored: smash box. Love eye primer, but not interested in other items. Under eye primer is okay but I’m looking for a new one
this was such a fun video idea!!
I'm shocked you didn't put in Persona or Sigma 🙀
Milani is my favorite drugstore brand. I have never tried anything that was a complete fail from them. I wish they would bring back the Multitasker powder though.
Loved this video. I'm surprised Milani is above Elf for you. Crazy how ABH moved down in the past years.